El buen Alemán

It’s something between A Foreign Affair, Witness for the Prosecution, and Charlotte Gray. We of course also get Germany in year zero. Let Casablanca sleep if you want to talk about the style of the post-war 1940s and films from bombed-out Berlin... Personally, I was very skeptical about The Good German because of the cast, but in the end, I have to admit that at least Clooney proved to me that he's not just a star. On the other hand, I began to have doubts about Maguire. However, the fact that Cate is the new Katharine Hepburn was already confirmed in The Aviator. In fact, she could now play all of her films in her own style and participate in exact copies of her actual films. Simply more films that leave the retro label far behind and meld it into enjoyment. (08.11.2010)

El proyecto prometedor de Soderbergh se quedó muy lejos, demasiado lejos de las expectativas. Tobey Maguire como el rudo es más bien gracioso que alguien que se pueda tomar en serio, y George Clooney recibe todo el filme solo bromas, incluso de Maguire, eso ya es demasiado. (04.06.2007)

Steven Soderbergh is playing with the form and couldn't care less about the story. As a fan of Hitchcock's films and film noir in general, I like the elements he uses, such as the black and white cinematography, the use of archival footage, and the overall visual style reminiscent of the 1940s and 1950s. However, that doesn't change the fact that Clooney's acting sometimes feels like a parody. The story itself is quite boring and doesn't have anything to captivate you. Were there really no German actors available? (28.03.2014)